Repository navigation
as-> indentation spec should not be 2 #433
Description
as-> indentation spec should not be 2 It creates the following indentation, which is not desirable, in my eyes. Note how the two lines under it are indented differently.
(-> 123
(+ 1)
(as-> x
(+ x 1)
(- 1 x)))
I'm not exactly sure what indentation spec to use though. The problem, of course, is that if you want to use as-> without a surrounding threading macro, and you don't have the two first argument on the first line, the second should be indented differently than the rest. However, I think the situation above is more common than that.
Activity
Malabarba commentedon Oct 12, 2017
I think pretty much any macro with an indent spec will be poorly indented by Emacs inside a threading macro. I'm not sure changing the spec for
as->is the best solution to that.bbatsov commentedon Jul 16, 2019
I agree with @Malabarba. There's little we can do in such situations, as the indentation specs reflect the typical usage of the forms. No one else has complained about this problem, so I guess it's safe to assume it's not very common.
kommen commentedon Aug 5, 2019
For completeness sake: When running
cljfmton our project it brings up a bunch of examples of exactly what @oskarkv mentioned. Looking at our codebase, we always and only useas->within another threading macro, following the advice from https://stuartsierra.com/2018/07/15/clojure-donts-thread-as